Bench Boost only pays off when your four backups can actually score points, not just start. GW5 has a decent spread of cheap players with attractive fixtures, so the question is whether your bench matches that profile or is full of blanks waiting to happen.
What matters this week
- Fixtures at the cheap end: Manchester City host Sunderland, and that single fixture produces three of the highest bench-tier xP scores on this list: Guéhi (4.95 xP), Gvardiol (4.92 xP) and Donnarumma (4.51 xP).
- Form clashing with price: Tarkowski is £6.0m but arrives with form of 7.2, well clear of anyone else in this data. Schade (form 7.5, £6.0m) is the standout attacking name at budget prices.
- Ownership as a minutes proxy: Nmecha’s 4.76 xP comes at just 0.5% selected, which is worth noting since low ownership at this price point often means less nailed minutes than the data alone suggests.
How to weigh it
Fixture strength and form should carry more weight than raw price when picking bench players, because a £5.5m player with form of 5.5 (Murillo, 4.69 xP) is a safer source of points than a similarly priced player with weaker underlying form. When two players sit close on xP, use selected-by percentage as a tiebreaker: Gvardiol at 20.6% and Guéhi at 18.5% both suggest the market already trusts their minutes, whereas outliers like Nmecha at 0.5% carry more risk despite a strong headline number.
Top picks by position
Goalkeepers
Suzuki leads on xP (4.83) despite a middling 3.5 form, playing away at Tottenham. Kinsky (4.61 xP, form 4.0) is the higher-owned option at 18.5% and starts at home against Villa.
Defenders
Guéhi (4.95 xP) and Gvardiol (4.92 xP) both benefit from City’s home fixture against Sunderland and carry the form and ownership to back it up. Tarkowski’s 7.2 form is the best in this dataset at any position.
Midfielders
Schade is the clear standout: 4.68 xP with form of 7.5 at home to Chelsea. M.Sangaré (4.27 xP, form 5.5) offers a second Brentford option from the same fixture.
Forwards
Calvert-Lewin tops the list at 5.41 xP, at home to Crystal Palace, though his form sits at just 2.5. Barry (5.20 xP, form 3.5) offers similar fixture upside at home to Ipswich for less money.
Squad-fit notes
Bench Boost works best when your four picks are nailed starters, so cross-check these names against your own bench before committing. If your bench already includes two or three of Guéhi, Gvardiol, Schade or Tarkowski, the chip is close to a straightforward call this week.
If you are unsure
Default to holding the chip unless at least three of your bench players match names on this list. There is no penalty for waiting a week if your current bench doesn’t line up with the fixtures and form shown here.
See when to play your chips, based on your actual squad
fplwire reads your live FPL team and shows you your captain options, transfer targets, chip timing and mini league standings in one place. Free, and no account needed.