Captaincy this week is not a coin flip. The data separates into a clear top tier and a value tier, and the choice comes down to how much you trust raw expected points versus form and fixture upside.
What matters this week
- Expected points ceiling: Haaland leads the field at 8.43 xP, well clear of everyone else, and he plays at home against SUN.
- Form versus xP: João Pedro has the best current form of the group at 8.2, even though his xP of 6.56 sits behind Haaland’s, and he travels to BRE.
- Ownership and safety: Haaland is owned by 71.7% of managers and João Pedro by 74.2%, so both are low risk from a rank protection standpoint. Isak (22.6% owned, 6.46 xP, away at BOU) and Fernandes (42.8% owned, 5.96 xP, away at FUL) offer differentiation if you want to attack.
How to weigh it
When the top xP score is this far ahead of the pack, form and fixture become tie breakers rather than reasons to look elsewhere. Haaland’s 8.43 xP against a home fixture with SUN is the number to beat. João Pedro’s hot form (8.2) is tempting, but his xP of 6.56 shows the model still rates Haaland’s underlying output higher despite lower recent form (6.0). If you want a differential, Isak’s low ownership (22.6%) against his solid 6.46 xP is the strongest case, since he offers rank-gaining upside that the two heavily owned options cannot.
The pick
Haaland is the captain. His 8.43 xP is the highest of any player in this pool, comfortably ahead of João Pedro’s 6.56 and Isak’s 6.46. A home fixture against SUN, combined with his price tag of £15.5m reflecting his standing as the game’s premier goal threat, makes this the highest floor and highest ceiling pick available. With 71.7% ownership, missing out on his haul is also the bigger risk to your rank if you fade him.
Alternatives
João Pedro is the form play. His 8.2 form rating is the best of the top five, and at 74.2% ownership he is arguably the more crowded pick, but his 6.56 xP away at BRE keeps him a clear second choice rather than a co-favourite. Isak offers the differential route at 22.6% ownership with 6.46 xP away at BOU, a gap worth considering if you are chasing rank rather than protecting it. Fernandes, with 5.96 xP and 42.8% ownership away at FUL, is a reasonable playmaker option but sits behind all three forwards on the numbers. Thiago’s 5.85 xP is respectable, but his form of 1.2 is the lowest in this group by a wide margin, which makes him hard to trust this week.
The verdict
Take Haaland. The 8.43 xP figure, the home fixture, and the 71.7% ownership all point the same direction, and there is no data-backed reason to look past the clear top score in this pool this week.
See the captain pick for your own squad
fplwire reads your live FPL team and shows you your captain options, transfer targets, chip timing and mini league standings in one place. Free, and no account needed.